Concert Review – Paradise Lost (Lee’s Palace, Toronto, ON, 05/18/2025)

One of the pioneers of death and doom returned to Toronto after seven long years with a beyond flawless performance, sounding absolutely heavy, dark and vibrant.

OPENING ACTS: Nepenthe and Gigan

Concerts on a Sunday night are only truly fun when you don’t have to work the next morning, allowing you to enjoy the whole event to the fullest without checking the time every 30 seconds. Well, fortunately for all Torontonian fans of first-class Doom Metal, the iconic PARADISE LOST, with support from NEPENTHE and GIGAN, brought to the always cozy Lee’s Palace their undisputed The Devil Embraced North America 2025 exactly in the middle of the Victoria Day long weekend, meaning we could inhale all heaviness and doom blasted by one of the trailblazers of the style without worrying about the next day. A huge shout-out to Noel Peters of Inertia Entertainment for not only bringing Paradise Lost to Toronto after almost seven years, but for also fixing the issue with tickets from a few buyers that were showing Helmet instead of Paradise Lost, and another one to Keith Ibbitson of Metal Paparazzi for making magic with the photos of the opening bands as the lighting during both was way too red or too green, plus all the smoke, making it almost impossible to see the bands onstage. They looked like shadows only, to be fair.

The lighting might have been horrible for good photos, but the music by Guelph, Ontario-based Blackened Doom Metal outfit NEPENTHE, the first attraction of the night, was beyond amazing. Playing songs from their two EPs, those being Elegies of Loss and Doom (2020) and The Fading Promise of Tomorrow (2024), both available on Spotify (and I highly recommend you go listen to both), like the excellent Dawn, the band spearheaded by the multi-talented Konrad Schroeder, who has the undisputed ability of playing really complex beats and fills while at the same time delivering solid clean vocals and desperate harsh screams, kicked some serious ass onstage for the delight of everyone who was already at the venue. Seriously, those guys were an incredible opening act, and hopefully I’ll get to see them again on the stages of Toronto in the near future, because the reaction of the crowd to their austere, captivating songs was awesome.

Band members
Konrad Schroeder – vocals, drums, percussion
Scott Rice – lead guitars
Steven Rowlands – rhythm guitars
Chris Rowan – bass

After a quick break (which I used to go grab some food outside, as I was starving), it was time for a lot of noise, heaviness and smoke, courtesy of Chicago, Illinois’ own Progressive/Technical Death Metal entity GIGAN, and when I say there was a lot of smoke, believe, it was A LOT of smoke. Having released the beautifully titled album Anomalous Abstractigate Infinitessimus in 2024, which is by the way available in full on Spotify, the band formed of Jerry Kavouriaris, Eric Hersemann, Rajan Davis, and Nathan Cotton turned Lee’s Palace into a cauldron of violence and insanity, blasting heavier-than-hell sounds that would make your head explode if you were not wearing any type of ear protection. The smoke made it almost impossible to see the band members on stage, only their silhouettes, but that didn’t make their performance any less enjoyable. Eric’s riffs were utterly heavy and dissonant, and when you add to that the insane drumming by Nathan and the demented roars by Jerry, you have the perfect recipe for a brutal sonic chaos. In other words, if Gigan ever visit your city with their live concerts, don’t miss the chance of witnessing a tsunami of first-class noise.

Band members
Jerry Kavouriaris – vocals
Eric Hersemann – guitars
Rajan Davis – bass
Nathan Cotton – drums

PARADISE LOST

After the top-notch concerts by Nepenthe and Gigan, the crowd was more than ready for the feast of top-of-the-line Doom Metal by the main attraction of the night, the one and only PARADISE LOST. Although they’re not purely Doom Metal anymore, blending their core music with Death and Gothic Metal, plus a high dosage of Gothic Rock, the band spearheaded by the “voice of doom” Nick Holmes was finally back in Toronto after so many years, not only playing songs from their latest album Obsidian, released in 2020 (available on Spotify, and which fans in Toronto had never had the chance to see live), but from their entire career, including my favorite Paradise Lost songs of all time, Enchantment and The Last Time. These two were flawless, and the reaction of the fans to them was also beautiful to say the least.

Greg Mackintosh and Aaron Aedy were insane armed with their axes, blasting incredible riffs, solos, and headbanging nonstop like if they were part of the crowd. Steve Edmondson and Guido Zima made sure the venue kept trembling during the entire show with their demonic kitchen, and of course, Mr. Nick Holmes was perfect with both his clean and deep guttural vocals. Songs like As I Die, The Devil Embraced, and No Hope in Sight, which showcase the band’s strongest doom vein, simply darkened the atmosphere (in a very good way, of course) for the delight of the band’s most diehard fans. Add to that the absurdly catchy Say Just Words, and a stunning cover version for Bronski Beat’s Smalltown Boy, and there you have the perfect setlist for a very enjoyable and fun night of heavy music in Toronto. I don’t think it will take another seven years for Paradise Lost to return to the city again, and it doesn’t matter if it’s a holiday or in the middle of the week, or even if it’s Christmas Eve, I’ll be there. Because as the lyrics say in the closing song of the setlist, the excellent Ghosts, “for the ghosts, the ones to break me for Jesus Christ.”

Setlist
Enchantment
Forsaken
Pity the Sadness
Faith Divides Us – Death Unites Us
Eternal
One Second
The Enemy
As I Die
The Devil Embraced
The Last Time
No Hope in Sight
Say Just Words

Encore:
Embers Fire
Smalltown Boy (Bronski Beat cover)
Ghosts

Band members
Nick Holmes – vocals
Greg Mackintosh – lead guitars, keyboards
Aaron Aedy – rhythm guitars
Steve Edmondson – bass
Guido Zima – drums

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Album Review – Paradise Lost / The Plague Within (2015)

They’re the most amazing plague within the world of Doom and Gothic Metal, and they’re back with more of their unique dark music.

Rating4

paradise lost-the plague withinWhen the band in question are British Gothic/Doom Metal icons Paradise Lost, we all must forget about that disposable Goth teen attitude that infests thousands of websites, TV programs, YouTube channels and alternative nightclubs. These guys don’t need all those shenanigans to craft the darkest and most melancholic sounding you can think of, and they’ve been doing that with their faces “clean” for decades, releasing masterpieces such as Draconian Times and Icon. This is Doom Metal for grown-ups, and a true pleasure to listen to anytime of the day.

Now once again Mr. Nick Holmes and his crew offer us all their doomed excellence in The Plague Within, the 14th studio album in their stupendous career. Everything in the album was meticulously put together, from the album art to its obscure lyrics, without losing that raw feeling that made them famous worldwide two decades ago. If you think their previous album, Tragic Idol (2012), was a strong release, you’ll probably enjoy this new one as well, as it keeps up with the same level of complexity and deepness, but of course always providing the listener some fresh and exquisite elements to differentiate it from their other albums.

No Hope in Sight is a great tune to open the album, where its first few seconds take us back to the 90’s when Paradise Lost were rising to stardom. I believe everyone, including myself, loves how Nick can deliver some growls and his deep dark clean vocals at the same time, and of course those superb heavy riffs accompanied by the slow beats which are exactly what diehard fans of the band wanted to hear. Speeding up things a bit we have the excellent Terminal, with highlights to its truly obscure lyrics (“I can hope as silence and torture grows / The violence we now condemn infests our inner souls”) and to the amazing guitar duo by Greg Mackintosh and Aaron Aedy, enhancing the musicality to Blackened Doom (with even the vocals by Nick getting darker than usual). In An Eternity of Lies, an orchestral intro turns into a beautiful display of melancholy and hate, and as much as I enjoy guttural vocals, in my opinion Nick’s clean voice sounds simply perfect in this song.

paradise lostThe lyrics from the following song, Punishment Through Time, are perfect for the sounding provided by the band (“Neglect afraid to say / Repentance awaits / Rejected jaded decayed / A vengeance awaits”), and it’s practically impossible not to get thrilled by this tune. I see it as a modern version of the music in Draconian Times, boosted by the awesome riffs and solos by Greg and Aaron. And if you love when Paradise Lost let their doomed side take control of the music you’ll go crazy with Beneath Broken Earth, where Nick’s vocals are so demonic you might even feel disturbed with them, with highlights to the low-tuned bass lines by Steve Edmondson and the constant and dark beats by Adrian Erlandsson. Furthermore, the lugubrious shadow doesn’t give any sign of going away with Sacrifice the Flame, another beautiful composition of sorrow and pain led by the powerful voice by Nick. Long story short, it’s slow and soulful, and that’s all we need from Paradise Lost to have a good time.

When Victim of the Past starts just as somber as the previous tunes, you will notice how dark the second half of the album is, with the atmosphere created by the keyboard notes being amazingly gruesome while the rest of band delivers some solid obscure lines. However, Paradise Lost get a lot faster and heavier in Flesh from Bone, an old school Doom Metal tune with imposing lyrics (“See the righteous fall at the rise of the damned, denied / See others crawl in the hour demand and fight”), and when a band has a superb musician like Adrian on drums they can range from the slowest Doom Metal to the most bestial Black Metal flawlessly. Letting their Stoner Rock/Metal vein arise, Cry Out is an awesome pub-fighting song which will make you headbang and raise your beer to the band for sure, with the addition of an 80’s Gothic touch to make the whole experience even better. And lastly, the masters of the genre deliver the most traditional Doom Metal in Return to the Sun, where its symphonic/choir intro is a work-of-art and every element contained in the entire song is thoroughly connected. It doesn’t matter whether you prefer the harsh vocals by Nick or the funereal drums by Adrian, if you don’t fall in love for this song forget about Doom Metal, because that’s definitely not your cup of tea.

The deluxe edition of this beautiful album comes with three interesting bonus tracks: Fear of Silence, Never Look Away and Victim of the Past (which is a live recording of an orchestral version of the original song, by the way), and you can also enjoy or even study all its lyrics HERE. As long as Paradise Lost keep releasing strong albums like this one, maintaining the fires of darkness alive, they will always be the awe-inspiring plague within the world of Doom and Gothic Metal.

Best moments of the album: Terminal, Punishment Through Time, Sacrifice the Flame and Return to the Sun.

Worst moments of the album: Victim of the Past.

Released in 2015 Century Media

Track listing
1. No Hope in Sight 4:54
2. Terminal 4:28
3. An Eternity of Lies 5:58
4. Punishment Through Time 5:13
5. Beneath Broken Earth 6:09
6. Sacrifice the Flame 4:42
7. Victim of the Past 4:29
8. Flesh from Bone 4:19
9. Cry Out 4:31
10. Return to the Sun 5:44

Deluxe Edition bonus tracks
11. Fear of Silence 3:59
12. Never Look Away 5:17
13. Victim of the Past (Orchestral Version) 5:13

Band members
Nick Holmes – vocals
Greg Mackintosh – lead guitar
Aaron Aedy – rhythm guitar
Steve Edmondson – bass guitar
Adrian Erlandsson – drums