Concert Review – Tribulation (Lee’s Palace, Toronto, ON, 05/25/2025)

***Review by Kevin Ibbitson and photos by Keith Ibbitson of Metal Paparazzi***

OPENING ACTS: Unreqvited, Final Gasp and Early Moods

Thankfully the rain had stopped by the time us fans began to queue up in front of Lee’s Palace as Swedish goth/death metal band TRIBULATION and friends (UNREQVITED, FINAL GASP and EARLY MOODS) visited our fair city on their North America 2025 Tour, another great event brought to Toronto by Noel Peters of Inertia Entertainment. It was not a sold out show by any means, which was quite surprising since the these are all killer bands. Maybe the Scattered showers scared folks away. Who knows? Their loss I guess! They happened to miss out on a fantastic night of heavy metal sorcery. Ultimately the lower turn out made the show feel more intimate and Lee’s is a smaller venue anyway, besides, the crowd that showed up proved to be die-hard supporters (good on them!). All in all I would say that at least over 100 head bangers showed up in support.
The first band to play was UNREQVITED, out of our nations capital Ottawa, and they promptly set the mood with their brand of post-black/shoegaze which reminded me a lot of  the French band Alcest, which I didn’t mind because I’m a fan of them also. I found their music to be atmospheric and introspective as well as head-bobbing/banging. This band has fantastic vocals from soothing cleans to raspy black metal grumblings and howls. Although I could see that for some in the crowd that shoegaze was not exactly their cup of tea, they still appreciated the music set before them. By the way, if you enjoy that type of music, the band has recently released the album A Pathway to the Moon, and you can purchase it or stream it in full on BandCamp and on Spotify.

Setlist
The Starforger
Void Essence / Frozen Tears
The Autumn Fire

Band members
鬼 (Ghost) – vocals, all instruments
Victor Forest – guitars
Robin Parsons – bass
Alec Curren – drums

For those in the crowd that were feeling a bit drowsy, EARLY MOODS out of Los Angeles, California, bitch-slapped their asses and got the place buzzing. This band is so freaking awesome. They blasted us with their brand of energetically powerful doom metal and swagger. You get everything you need out of this band like energy, excitement, groove, sore necks and killer riffs. These guys are killer! I highly recommend that you check them out the next time they swing by town, you won’t be disappointed, and go check their music on BandCamp or Spotify, like their 2024 album A Sinner’s Past. The crowd absolutely loved this band and so do I. I also loved that these guys joined the crowd after their set and head-banged along side us in support of their fellow tour mates.

Setlist
Isolated
Blood Offerings
Return To Salem’s Gate
Live To Suffer
Soul Sorcery
A Sinner’s Past
Damnation

Band members
Alberto Alcaraz – vocals
Eddie Andrade – guitars
Oscar Hernandez – guitars
Elix Feliciano – bass
Chris Flores – drums

Next up was a band called FINAL GASP out of Boston, MA. This deathrock outfit kept the buzz going throughout the building with a highly energetic set. The lead singer Jake Murphy tried on several occasions to get a circle pit going but nobody took the bait but he did manage to get the crowd to come a little closer to the stage. It was a small crowd after all, but you can’t knock him for trying though. Even still, the crowd was receptive to Final Gasp and they put on a great performance for the crowd as it was their final show on this tour. I wouldn’t say no to seeing them again if they ever come back to town. Killer band, and you can enjoy their entire discography, like their most recent album Mourning Moon, released in 2023, in places like BandCamp and Spotify.

Setlist
Look Away
Climax Infinity
Mourning Moon
Apparition
Blood & Sulfur
Temptation
Homebound
Suicide

Band members
Jake Murphy – vocals
James Forsythe – guitars
Peter Micanovic – guitars
Sean Rose – bass
Eric Lester – drums

TRIBULATION

I last saw blackened-goth metallers TRIBULATION when they opened up for Opeth this past Thanksgiving and they impressed me, so I was delighted to hear that they were coming back to Toronto for their North American tour. Seriously, are there any shitty metal bands in Sweden? Because I haven’t found one yet. Swedish Metal is so consistent and Tribulation out of Arvika, Sweden are no slouch. They are an absolutely fantastic band, as you can see in their 2024 opus Sub Rosa in Æternum, available on several streaming services like Spotify. Tribulation put on another amazing show, ensorcelling and enchanting all of the die-hard supporters that showed up with unrelenting class. They are such a tight, professional band, you seriously can’t go wrong seeing them live. I look forward to seeing them again some day.

Setlist
The Unrelenting Choir
Tainted Skies
Nightbound
Hamartia
Suspiria De Profundis
Melancholia
In Remembrance
Hungry Waters
Saturn Coming Down
Murder In Red
Strange Gateways Beckon

Band members
Johannes Andersson – vocals, bass
Adam Zaars – guitars
Joseph Tholl – guitars
Oscar Leander – drums

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Album Review – U Kronakh / Archaic Dance of the Winds (2025)

Playing a harmonious blend of Atmospheric Black and Death Metal since their inception, this Ukrainian creature returns with their incendiary third opus.

Playing a harmonious blend of Atmospheric Black and Death Metal since their inception in 2020, with lyrics predominantly dedicated to the raw mysticism of the Carpathian Mountains and events of ancient times, Chernivtsi and Lviv, Ukraine-based creature U Kronakh has just unleashed their third full-length offering, titled The Archaic Dance of Winds (or “Архаїчний Танець Вітрів” in their mother tongue), following up on their 2024 opus Night Devours Being (or “Ніч Поглинає Буття”). Mixed and mastered by Roman “Morvudd” Sapozhnikov, and once again featuring a grim artwork by Ksenia Vasylevska (aka Wintersomnia), the new album by Wormwood on vocals, Voidger on the guitars and bass, and Lycane on drums showcases more of the project’s experimentations with an array of styles, resulting in a unique blend that doesn’t follow any rules nor fit into any specific music genre, as the band believes creativity exists precisely for such freedom.

The melancholic guitar lines by Voidger kick off the nine-minute atmospheric tune titled Black Mountain, offering an overdose of Post-Black Metal sounds as part of their core Atmospheric Black and Death Metal. Then investing in a more direct Black Metal sound with Death Metal nuances we have The River Named Opir, with Wormwood’s harsh vociferations exhaling hatred and obscurity while Lycane hammers his drums with tons of energy and fury. Into Lightless, Uncharted Depths keeps the atmosphere dense and pensive while adding an extra touch of melody to their core Atmospheric Black Metal thanks to the striking riffs and solos by Voidger; and the trio sounds in total and absolute sync in Night Visions Fade, breathing fire and darkness through their sonic weapons, with the lancinating roars by Wormwood reeking of insanity. Lastly, it’s time to break our necks headbanging to the closing tune About Those Who Are Silent Now, with Voidger and Lycane building a Stygian ambience perfect for Wormwood’s devilish gnarls.

Fans of bands the likes of Ezkaton, Silvern, Harakiri For The Sky, Ellende, and Moonsorrow, among several others, will have an absolute blast listening to Archaic Dance of the Winds, another solid step forward in the dark and exciting path taken by U Kronakh in their short but extremely prolific career so far. The uncanny musicians behind U Kronakh are waiting for you armed with their atmospheric sounds on Facebook and on Instagram, and don’t forget to also stream their entire discography on Spotify (or any other streaming service), and above all that, to purchase Archaic Dance of the Winds from BandCamp, or click HERE for all things U Kronakh. Their music is just as mysterious and distinctive as their name, and I’m sure it won’t take long for the band to stun us all once again with the successor of Archaic Dance of the Winds, because if there’s one thing that the guys from U Kronakh know how to do, that’s to keep working hard and crafting high quality grim music nonstop.

Best moments of the album: The River Named Opir and Night Visions Fade.

Worst moments of the album: None.

Released in 2025 Archivist Records

Track listing
1. Black Mountain 9:15
2. The River Named Opir 6:17
3. Into Lightless, Uncharted Depths 9:08
4. Night Visions Fade 7:31
5. About Those Who Are Silent Now 7:44

Band members
Wormwood – vocals
Voidger – guitars, bass
Lycane – drums

Concert Review – Swallow The Sun (The Velvet Underground, Toronto, ON, 02/21/2025)

A night of sheer doom, darkness and melancholy in the form of first-class heavy music took the skies of Toronto this Friday night.

OPENING ACTS: Snakes Of Russia, Ghost Bath and Harakiri For The Sky

A few days after the heaviest snow storm the city of Toronto has seen for quite some time, The Velvet Underground hosted the Shining Over North America Tour 2025 with the bands SNAKES OF RUSSIA, GHOST BATH, HARAKIRI FOR THE SKY and SWALLOW THE SUN, and of course Keith Ibbitson of Metal Paparazzi and I were there to cover such an amazing event. Well, unfortunately due to the insane traffic to get to Toronto AND also inside the city, it was impossible for several concert goers to arrive in time for the performance by United States-based Darkwave/Electronic/Ambient act SNAKES OF RUSSIA, including Keith and I. I honestly have no idea how the show was, if the crowd enjoyed it or not, as while Snakes of Russia was playing I was desperately trying to find a parking lot where most spots were not taken by huge snow banks. At least before the show I had some time to listen to their 2023 album True Surrender, available on BandCamp and on Spotify, and although it’s not my cup of tea I must admit it’s a really cool album for fans of the darkest side of electronic music.

Band members
Joseph Holiday – vocals, all instruments

When I weas finally able to get inside the venue, American Depressive/Post-Black Metal entity GHOST BATH had already started their setlist, but at least in this case I had plenty of time to enjoy their harsh and sinister performance, led by the visceral, anguished screams by vocalist and guitarist Nameless. One of the main issues with The Velvet Underground, if not their biggest issue, is the fact the stage is way too low, almost as if it doesn’t really exist, and it’s really tough to see the bands performing there unless you’re two feet from the “stage”. Add to that a few pillars in the middle of the venue, and there you have the perfect atmosphere to mainly listen to the music played without seeing anything. Furthermore, Keith couldn’t make it in time for Ghost Bath, and as my mobile pictures of the show are beyond nasty, there isn’t anything to show about them on this review. You can still enjoy their music on BandCamp and on Spotify, like their 2021 album Self Loather, and I highly recommend seeing those guys live if you enjoy such a caustic type of Black Metal.

Band members
Nameless – vocals, guitars
Caleb Cheslock – guitars
Liam Frith – guitars
Josh Jaye – bass
Alec Martin – drums

Then after all that hassle to get to Toronto, the shitty traffic, the excruciating task of finding a parking spot, and so on, I was already getting very tired and ready to go back home to relax a little, but fortunately Austria’s own Post-Black Metal masters HARAKIRI FOR THE SKY hit the stage for the most electrifying performance of the night, waking me up and inspiring me to headbang and raise my horns nonstop to their fantastic music. Playing mostly songs from their 2021 album Mӕre and their newborn masterpiece Scorched Earth, the band led by frontman J.J. and guitarist M.S. kicked some serious ass on stage, investing all of their energy into each song played, and with minimal talk in between songs. I simply loved seeing them live for the first time, and songs like With Autumn I’ll Surrender, Without You I’m Just a Sad Song, Fire, Walk With Me, and Sing for the Damage We’ve Done (all available on Spotify) sounded flawless, superb and touching, and the reaction from every single person to their classy performance was a thing of beauty, which clearly indicated it won’t take long for one of the best bands of the current metal scene worldwide to return to Toronto soon.

Setlist
Keep Me Longing
With Autumn I’ll Surrender
Fire, Walk With Me
Without You I’m Just a Sad Song
Sing for the Damage We’ve Done
Calling the Rain

Band members
J.J. – vocals
M.S. – guitars
Marrok – guitars, backing vocals
P.G. – bass
Kerim “Krimh” Lechner – drums

SWALLOW THE SUN

The name of the band says it all. After a quick break, it was time for the darkest show of the night, courtesy of Finland’s Melodic Doom/Death Metal titans SWALLOW THE SUN, and it was indeed a dark, pensive, doomed and visceral concert. Vocalist Mikko Kotamaki and his henchmen were on fire during their entire set, blending their old material with their newest albums Moonflowers (2021) and Shining (2024), with the sequence of Woven Into Sorrow, Charcoal Sky, MelancHoly, New Moon and Night Will Forgive Us sounding and feeling as heavy and obscure as possible. The encore was just as doomed, with November Dust and Swallow (Horror, Part 1), and their diehard fans were having an amazing time with their scorching riffs, pounding drums and visceral energy. It was a somewhat late show for most of us, but in the end it was a fantastic night of contemporary heavy music, and I’ll surely be there anytime Swallow The Sun are back in town with their undisputed doom.

Setlist
Velvet Chains
Innocence Was Long Forgotten
What I Have Become
Firelights
Under the Moon & Sun
Woven Into Sorrow
Charcoal Sky
New Moon
MelancHoly
Night Will Forgive Us
Plague of Butterflies: Pt. I: Losing the Sunsets

Encore:
November Dust
Swallow (Horror, Part 1)

Band members
Mikko Kotamaki – vocals
Juha Raivio – guitars, keyboards
Juho Raiha – guitars
Matti Honkonen – bass
Juuso Raatkainen – drums

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Album Review – Groza / Nadir (2024)

Driven by emotion, anger and sadness, this German Black Metal horde will strike you like a lightning storm to the sound of their thrilling new album.

Groza, or “Гроза” in Cyrillic, which means “lightning storm”, “horror” or “disgust” in a few Slavic languages, are an up-and-coming Black Metal band formed in 2016 in Mühldorf am Inn, Bavaria, Germany, crafting a sound driven by emotion, anger and sadness, combining searing melodies, raging blast beats and melancholy induced clean guitar passages into a melodic, dynamic blend, which is exactly what you’ll get in their new album Nadir. Recorded, edited, mixed and produced by the band’s own founder P.G., mastered by David Pilz, and with the guitars re-amped by Georg Traschwandtner, the new album by the aforementioned P.G. on lead vocals, bass, guitars, orchestration and samples, U.A. on lead guitars and backing vocals, and T.H.Z. on drums is perfect for fans of Harakiri For The Sky, Mgla, Uada, and Alcest, delivering dark and melodic music for our avid ears.

The atmospheric, haunting intro Soul : Inert sets the stage for the trio to darken our minds and souls with Asbest, a powerful Melodic Black Metal tune with progressive and experimental nuances where P.G. roars with tons of anger in his blackened heart supported by the thunderous beats by T.H.Z., not to mention how metallic their riffs sound and feel. Then we have Dysthymian Dreams, the first single of the album, offering our avid ears eight minutes of Black Metal magic led by the sharp, piercing guitars by P.G. and U.A., or in other words, it’s a brutal yet melodic and enfolding aria of darkness by Groza. Equal. Silent. Cold. keeps the atmosphere burning to the sound of P.G.’s infernal vociferations while the drums by T.H.Z. exhale old school Black Metal, resulting in one of the most ferocious and detailed songs of the album; and it’s time for a nine-minute musical journey through the most obscure corners of the mind in Deluge, reminding me of some of the most recent creations by Gaerea, with their riffs and blast beats mercilessly devouring our rotten souls. Lastly, featuring J.J. & M.S. of bands like Kard and Harakiri for the Sky, we have Daffodils, a beyond dense, multi-layered and pensive Black Metal aria with lots of elements from Post-Black Metal and Atmospheric Black Metal, where the drums by T.H.Z. sound sensational throughout the entire song and with all agony and despair flowing from the last part of the song being absolutely climatic and piercing.

The music by Groza is haunting, mesmerizing, evil and ethereal all at once, and Nadir is the perfect depiction of the band’s musical power, talent and focus. Hence, don’t forget to give such a distinct horde a shout on Facebook and on Instagram, to stream their music on Spotify, and of course to purchase a copy of the flammable Nadir from their own BandCamp page, from AOP Records, from Napalm Records, from Indiemerchstore, from MVD Entertainment, or click HERE for all digital platforms. Because Groza do not just play Black Metal – they take Black Metal to new and exciting heights.

Best moments of the album: Dysthymian Dreams and Equal. Silent. Cold.

Worst moments of the album: None.

Released in 2024 AOP Records

Track listing
1. Soul : Inert 1:21
2. Asbest 6:54
3. Dysthymian Dreams 8:10
4. Equal. Silent. Cold. 6:59
5. Deluge 9:18
6. Daffodils 9:53

Band members
P.G. – lead vocals, bass, guitars, orchestration, samples
U.A. – backing vocals, lead guitars
T.H.Z. – drums

Guest musicians
J.J. and M.S. – vocals on “Daffodils”
“Bandhouse” crew – choir on “Daffodils”

Album Review – Agrypnie / Erg (2024)

This German Progressive and Post-Black Metal force is back with its seventh studio album, their most aggressive album to date where every instrument attacks from every angle.

Founded in 2004 by songwriter Torsten, who is also active in the bands Nocte Obducta, Theotoxin, and Suel, as well as other musical projects, Groß-Gerau, Hesse, Germany-based Progressive/Post-Black Metal act Agrypnie has developed into a significant force in the Black Metal scene over the years. Now in 2024 the duo formed of the aforementioned Torsten on vocals, guitars, bass, keyboards and programming, and Flo (Benighted, Schammasch) on drums returns with their seventh studio album, titled Erg, Agrypnie’s most aggressive album to date where every instrument attacks from every angle, almost overwhelmingly so if not for the clear and cutting recording and the band’s enviously sharp execution. Recorded, mixed and mastered by Phil Hillen and Torsten at SU-2 Studio, and with artwork and photography by Marco Klein of syn2, Erg displays considerable daring and depth, as while “Black Metal” in foundation, the album’s songwriting crests and crashes with kaleidoscopic wonder and cathartic urgency alike.

Featuring guest vocals by Phil Jonas (of Secrets of the Moon and CRONE), Aus rauchlosem Feuer (“from smokeless fire”) is atmospheric and enfolding from the very first second, evolving into a Black Metal beast led by the scorching roars and riffs by Torsten while Flo hammers his drums nonstop, followed by Meer ohne Wasser, or “sea without water”, offering sluggish Doom Metal-infused beats and riffs while also exploding into sheer obscurity and madness, with Flo once again dictating the pace with his Black Metal beats. Then we have Sturm, or “storm”, with guest vocals by Edmond Karban aka Hupogrammos (of Dordeduh), venturing through the realms of pure Atmospheric Black Metal and with Torsten sounding like a metal machine armed with all his instruments; whereas the Stygian, grim interlude Blut – Teil I, or “blood – part I”, sets the tone for Blut – Teil II (“blood – part II”), featuring guest vocalist P.G. (of Groza), bringing forward another round of their trademark Post-Black Metal boosted by the intricate and visceral drumming by Flo.

The second half of the album begins with a song just as multi-layered and vile as its predecessors, titled Entität, or “entity”, with Torsten embellishing the airwaves with his classy riffs and bass lines, or in other words, it’s a very detailed song that will inspire us all to bang our heads nonstop together with the duo, exploding into the Black Metal attack titled Stunde des Wolfes (“hour of the wolf”), where the duo extracts the harshest, most piercing sounds form their instruments, and with Torsten delivering some devilish vociferations until the very end. Geister, or “ghosts”, is very experimental and atmospheric for the most part of it, with only its last part being Agrypnie’s core sound, but of course it’s still a very good song; whereas lastly the duo will rip our souls apart with the amazing Unter Sand, or “under sand”, offering our avid ears an avalanche of strident riffs, classic blast beats and anguished vocal lines, ending the album on a climatic and introspective note.

Rich sonically and in emotion, majestic even when plumbing the depths of melancholy, Erg is a tour de force of wide-screen Black Metal regardless of “progressive” or “post-” appellations. Hence, don’t forget to give Torsten and Flo a shout on Facebook and on Instagram, staying up to date with their news and tour dates, to subscribe to their YouTube channel and to check them out on Spotify for more of their music, and to grab your copy of Erg from AOP Records in Europe and in the US, from Napalm Records, from MVD Entertainment (US only), or from several digital platforms by clicking HERE. It’s a known fact that Agrypnie’s eighth studio album is already in the works, and it will be interesting to see their musical evolution form Erg to their upcoming release. Until then, simply give Erg countless spins, and let the fulminating music by Agrypnie embrace you in pitch black darkness.

Best moments of the album: Aus rauchlosem Feuer, Entität and Stunde des Wolfes.

Worst moments of the album: Geister.

Released in 2024 AOP Records

Track listing
1. Aus rauchlosem Feuer 7:28
2. Meer ohne Wasser 7:02
3. Sturm 6:00
4. Blut – Teil I 2:06
5. Blut – Teil II 5:16
6. Entität 7:24
7. Stunde des Wolfes 6:04
8. Geister 5:32
9. Unter Sand 6:46

Band members
Torsten – vocals, guitars, bass, keyboards, programming
Flo – drums

Guest musicians
Phil Jonas – vocals on “Aus rauchlosem Feuer”
P.G. – vocals on “Blut – Teil I” and “Blut – Teil II”
Edmond Karban – vocals on “Sturm”